Written by Stephen Breimer, Alan Jay Glueckman and Boon Collins
Directed by William Asher
Starring Susan Tyrrell, Jimmy McNichol, Bo Svenson and Julia Duffy
USA, 1982
BUTCHER, BAKER, NIGHTMARE MAKER is undeniably a great title, but it does little to describe the contents of this movie. It was also released as NIGHT WARNING, which is equally anti-descriptive. Whatever you want to call it, this flick was surprisingly entertaining and deserves to be better known.
Jimmy McNichol plays a high school student who's been raised by his aunt (Susan Tyrrell) since his parents died in a car accident when he was a little boy. Incidentally, this car crash opens the movie and it’s an intense, realistic and horrifying sequence. The aunt becomes extremely protective of her nephew, which is putting it mildly. She's devoted her entire life to raising him, and the prospect of his graduating from high school and going away to college is not something she's prepared to accept.
In fact, she's prepared to do just about anything to keep him from leaving.
Tyrrell is incredible in this movie. She gives us one of those characters who initially seems merely overbearing, but the more time you spend with her, the more you realize she's completely out of her mind. She's manipulative, possessive, sexually inappropriate and increasingly dangerous, and Tyrrell throws herself into the role with such conviction that it's hard to take your eyes off her. There are plenty of crazy mothers in horror movies, but crazy aunts don't get nearly as much attention. Tyrrell deserves a place in the pantheon.
Complicating matters is a murder investigation led by a police detective played by Bo Svenson, who turns out to be a spectacularly unpleasant individual. He's corrupt, aggressive and viciously homophobic, and he becomes convinced that our young hero’s high school basketball coach is involved in the crime.
What's interesting is that the coach is gay, and the movie treats him with a surprising degree of sympathy and respect, especially for an early-'80s exploitation picture. The detective, meanwhile, throws around homophobic slurs and seems more interested in persecuting gay people than solving the murder. It's an unexpected subplot, and one that gives the movie a little more substance than I anticipated.
I had a good time with BUTCHER, BAKER, NIGHTMARE MAKER, though I think it loses some momentum toward the end. Once the various secrets start coming out, the story becomes a little more conventional, and the final stretch isn't quite as much fun as everything leading up to it.
Still, Susan Tyrrell alone makes this worth seeing. Her performance is so wonderfully unhinged that I'm surprised it isn't better known among horror fans.

No comments:
Post a Comment