Wednesday, October 28, 2026

Horrorfest 2026: Clayface

CLAYFACE
Written by Mike Flanagan and Hossein Amini
Story by Mike Flanagan

Directed by James Watkins

Starring Tom Rhys Harries, Naomi Ackie, Max Minghella and David Dencik

USA, 2026

When I was a kid, I remember reading a Batman comic book that explained the histories of the various villains who had called themselves Clayface over the years. There were four or five of them, if I remember correctly, and I was fascinated by the idea that this relatively obscure Batman villain had gone through so many different incarnations. I don't remember much about the individual characters, but for some reason that comic book stuck with me.

So I was intrigued when I heard that DC was making a CLAYFACE movie, although I also thought it was a pretty strange choice for the new DC cinematic universe. Of all the characters they could have used to help establish this new continuity, they went with Clayface? Okay…

I was especially interested to learn that the movie was going to be an actual horror film rather than a conventional superhero adventure. That seemed like a promising approach, considering the character's grotesque shapeshifting abilities.

Tom Rhys Harries plays a rising movie star whose career is destroyed when a gangster horribly disfigures his face. Desperate to restore his appearance, he seeks help from a scientist (Naomi Ackie) who's developed an experimental treatment capable of regenerating damaged tissue. The treatment works, but it also gives him the ability to transform his body into just about anything. Unfortunately, he has a little trouble controlling it.

There's some great body-horror stuff here, and I appreciated the filmmakers' willingness to make things genuinely disgusting. One particularly memorable sequence involves our hero (or villain?) experiencing some unexpected changes to his face while flying on an airplane. His eyelids begin fusing shut, and he attempts to separate them with a pair of scissors while the plane bounces around in turbulence. It's an incredibly unpleasant scene, in the best possible way.

There are several moments like that, and the effects are generally terrific. The movie certainly doesn't shy away from the more horrifying possibilities of a guy whose flesh can melt, stretch and rearrange itself.

Unfortunately, the story surrounding all this is kind of a mess.

Clayface himself is a pretty empty character, although maybe that's intentional. He's an actor whose entire identity is tied to his appearance, and now he's literally lost his face. You'd think the filmmakers could do something with that. Instead, it eventually turns into a fairly generic story about a guy with superpowers taking revenge on the mobsters who wronged him.

I also couldn't help thinking about THE SUBSTANCE, which explored some similar territory involving beauty, identity and grotesque physical transformation. CLAYFACE has some impressive effects, but THE SUBSTANCE did this kind of thing better, and with considerably more purpose and focus.

And then there's the question of Batman. I understand that this is supposed to be a standalone horror movie, and I'm perfectly happy to watch a movie about a Batman villain without Batman in it. But since the whole thing takes place in his universe, I did find myself wondering where the guy was while all this craziness was going on. Isn't this exactly the sort of thing he ought to be investigating? There’s probably a hand-wavey explanation. Oh, this is before Batman became Batman. Or, he’s busy doing other shit. I get it. Still. Even if Batman was real, he wouldn’t be able to bust up every crime all the time. Still, you set a movie in Gotham City and let me get bored enough, eventually I’m going to start daydreaming about Batman. Okay?

Oh, and the soundtrack. There are some aggressively obvious needle drops that feel like the filmmakers are trying awfully hard to make everything seem cool. Sometimes a song can make a scene. Sometimes it can make a scene suck.


No comments:

Post a Comment